What’s the realistic first‑year plan (quotes, binds, retention)?

TL;DR: Niche focus, daily pipeline, and early renewal discipline beat spray‑and‑pray.

Answer

Pick 1–2 niches, set daily outreach and quoting cadence, track quote→bind weekly, and embed renewal touchpoints from the start. Ask for reviews post‑bind and build referral partners to compound growth.

Alright, let’s get into it. A realistic first-year plan for a scratch agency needs to balance ambition with the reality of starting from zero. You’re building a foundation, so the focus should be on activity, consistency, and creating a pipeline that pays off in years two and three. Here’s how I’d map it out:

1. Quotes

Goal: 1,000 quotes in Year 1.
- That’s about 20 quotes per week if you’re working 50 weeks. It’s aggressive, but achievable if you’re disciplined and leveraging technology like comparative raters and automation tools.
Why It Matters:
- Quoting is your lifeblood in Year 1. The more quotes you generate, the more opportunities you have to bind policies and build your book. But don’t just quote for the sake of quoting—focus on pre-qualifying prospects to improve your hit ratio (more on that below).

2. Binds

Goal: 200 binds in Year 1.
- That’s a 20% hit ratio (200 binds out of 1,000 quotes), which is realistic for a new agency. If you’re quoting the right prospects and following up consistently, this is absolutely doable.
Breakdown:
- Personal Lines: Expect smaller premiums but higher volume. You might bind 150 personal lines policies at an average premium of $1,500, which gives you $225,000 in premium.
- Commercial Lines: These take longer to close but offer higher premiums. If you bind 50 small commercial policies at an average premium of $5,000, that’s $250,000 in premium.
- Total Premium: $475,000 in Year 1, which translates to roughly $57,000 in commission at a 12% average commission rate.

3. Retention

Goal: 80% retention rate.
- Retention is critical because your renewals in Year 2 will form the foundation of your agency’s growth. If you bind 200 policies in Year 1 and retain 80%, you’ll have 160 policies renewing in Year 2.
How to Achieve It:
- Onboarding: Make a killer first impression by walking clients through their policies and setting expectations for service.
- Proactive Touchpoints: Check in with clients 90 days before renewal to address any concerns and prevent shopping.
- Claims Support: Be their advocate during claims—it’s a huge trust builder.

4. Activity Metrics

Daily Goals:
- Prospecting Calls/Emails: 20–30 per day.
- Appointments/Meetings: 5–10 per week.
- Follow-Ups: 10–15 per day.
Why It Matters:
- Insurance sales are a numbers game. If you’re not consistently prospecting and following up, you’re leaving money on the table. Use a CRM like Agency Zoom to track your activity and stay organized.

5. Tools to Help You Hit These Goals

Comparative Rater: Speeds up quoting and helps you handle higher volumes.
VoIP System: Makes it easy to manage calls and track client interactions.
CRM: Keeps your pipeline organized and ensures no lead falls through the cracks.
Automation Tools: Use email drip campaigns to nurture leads and stay top of mind.

6. Mindset for Year 1

Be Relentless: You’re going to hear “no” a lot. That’s fine. Every “no” gets you closer to a “yes.”
Focus on Relationships: Even if someone doesn’t buy today, they might in six months. Stay in touch.
Play the Long Game: Year 1 is about planting seeds. The real payoff comes in Years 2 and 3 when your renewals start stacking up.

Final Thoughts

If you stick to this plan—1,000 quotes, 200 binds, and 80% retention—you’ll have a solid foundation for growth. By Year 2, you’ll start seeing the compounding effect of renewals, and by Year 3, you’ll be in a position to scale.

Submit Interest Form: Let’s Have A No Pressure Alignment Chat

How Tague Alliance helps

Resources you can leverage to figure out your marketing, prospecting, etc.