What marketing & sales systems should a scratch agency use?

TL;DR: Pair a pipeline CRM, nurture automation, reviews, and referral systems.

Answer

Set daily outreach targets in a pipeline CRM, nurture with email/text automations, build review requests into post‑bind workflows, and create referral partner cadences. Track quote→bind and retention monthly.

When you’re starting a scratch agency, your marketing and sales systems need to be lean, effective, and scalable. You don’t have the luxury of wasting time or money on tools that don’t deliver. The goal is to build a tech stack that drives lead generation, streamlines your sales process, and keeps you organized while you’re juggling a million other things. Here’s what I’d recommend:

1. Agency Management System (AMS)

  • Why You Need It:
    This is your operational backbone. An AMS keeps all your client data, policies, and billing info in one place. It’s essential for staying organized and avoiding costly mistakes.
  • Top Options for Scratch Agencies:
    • HawkSoft: Great for agencies that want a balance of affordability and functionality.
    • Momentum (formerly NowCerts): A budget-friendly option with solid integrations and a growing list of features and capabilities in a modern technology platform.
    • QQ Catalyst: User-friendly and designed for smaller agencies.
  • Pro Tip: Look for an AMS that integrates seamlessly with your CRM and comparative rater to avoid double data entry .

2. Customer Relationship Management (CRM)

  • Why You Need It:
    A CRM helps you track leads, manage your sales pipeline, and automate follow-ups. It’s the key to staying on top of prospects and turning them into clients.
  • Top Options for Scratch Agencies:
    • AgencyZoom: Tailored for insurance agencies, with features like automated email campaigns and sales tracking .
  • Pro Tip: Use your CRM to set up automated drip campaigns for leads who don’t convert right away. Consistent follow-up is where the magic happens .

3. Comparative Rater

  • Why You Need It:
    A comparative rater lets you quote multiple carriers quickly, which is crucial for providing competitive options to your clients.
  • Top Options for Scratch Agencies:
    • PL Rater: A solid choice for personal lines.
    • EZLynx: Offers both rating and AMS capabilities, which can be a two-in-one solution.
  • Pro Tip: Make sure your rater integrates with your AMS to streamline the quoting process .

4. Marketing Automation Tools

  • Why You Need It:
    Marketing automation saves you time and ensures you’re consistently engaging with prospects and clients.
  • Top Options for Scratch Agencies:
    • Mailchimp or Constant Contact: For email marketing campaigns.
    • Levitate: A lightweight tool for personalized email outreach.
  • Pro Tip: Use automation to send birthday emails, renewal reminders, and cross-sell opportunities. These small touches build loyalty .

5. Lead Generation Tools

  • Why You Need It:
    Leads are the lifeblood of your agency. Without a steady flow of prospects, you’re dead in the water.
  • Top Options for Scratch Agencies:
    • Canopy Connect: Simplifies the process of collecting client data for quotes.
    • Facebook Ads Manager: Great for running hyper-local ad campaigns.
    • Google Ads: Perfect for targeting high-intent search traffic.
  • Pro Tip: Start with a small ad budget and test different campaigns to see what works. Focus on niches like renters or small business owners to maximize ROI .

6. Phone and Communication Systems

  • Why You Need It:
    Clear, efficient communication is non-negotiable. A good phone system keeps you connected with clients and prospects.
  • Top Options for Scratch Agencies:
    • RingCentral: A reliable VoIP system with call tracking and analytics.
    • Lightspeed Voice: Designed specifically for insurance agencies.
    • Slack or Microsoft Teams: For internal team communication.
  • Pro Tip: Use call tracking to measure the effectiveness of your marketing campaigns .

7. Reporting and Analytics

  • Why You Need It:
    You can’t improve what you don’t measure. Analytics tools help you track your performance and identify areas for growth.
  • Top Options for Scratch Agencies:
    • AgencyZoom or AgencyIQ (formerly DONNA AI by Aureus Analytics): Both offer built-in reporting features.
    • Google Analytics: For tracking website traffic and conversions.
  • Pro Tip: Review your data monthly to spot trends and adjust your strategy accordingly .

Final Thoughts

The key to building a successful scratch agency is to keep things simple and scalable. Start with the essentials—AMS, CRM, comparative rater—and layer on additional tools as your agency grows. If you’re feeling overwhelmed, let’s prioritize based on your immediate needs.  Let’s tackle it together.

Submit Interest Form: Let’s Have A No Pressure Alignment Chat

How Tague Alliance helps

  • We connect you with the various technology vendors that you may need based on your vision for how you want to operate your independent insurance agency.

Related answers